Bonding tiles old or new?

Neighbour’s have just had a new roof and their roofer has bonded in the original very old tiles from when these houses were constructed 1950-60’s into my 5-6 year old roof. The old tiles have also been painted previously. They have used a bonding gutter in between but have put old tiles every other tile going down my roof front and back. Should the roofer not have found similar new tiles like mine and used them? Rather than the old painted tiles which were obviously at the end of their service life which is obviously why the neighbour was changing their roof.

Asked by Andy on 28th Jul 2023
Expert Trade Answers
"The tiles should have been replaced with new tiles as they would have a full life whereas old tiles may be more fragile / prone to breaking from weathering."
Answered on 1st Aug 2023 - Member since Nov 2022 - report
"“Good Afternoon, hi Andy I Agree you are correct as it is affecting your property you are entitled to have a word with the roofer but this is a Normal act Carried out by roofers maybe he could of said it first”
Rob"
Answered on 12th Aug 2023 - Member since Jul 2023 - report
"The roofer should of changed the tiles and found similar ones to match the roof on the front and the back of the property"
Answered on 2nd Aug 2023 - Member since Jul 2023 - report
"The tradesman should have defiantly changed the tiles to new , and using the old ones that are past there used by dated and especially when they have clearly been painted by con men is just embarrassing take it further buddy !"
Answered on 28th Jul 2023 - Member since Jun 2023 - report
"A bonding gutter is used to split the roofs / party wall below , so there should be no joints hence the bonding gutter 🤔😏your half and their have so why they touched your tiles ?"
Answered on 28th Jul 2023 - Member since Dec 2022 - report
"Think u should have had a word with them roofers , as they had no right to touch your side and put old tiles on your side of the roof, and with moving your tiles you should get them back the same as it was !! Plus a plastic divider down the middle of both properties"
Answered on 28th Jul 2023 - Member since Jan 2018 - report
"Good morning it is normal for a roofer to use a bonding gutter between two houses, when if one roof has a different profile tile to the other so the battening is different for smaller or larger tiles as long as the bonding gutter has been fitted correctly you won’t have a problem, many thanks for your enquiry. Rob ARSW Roofing"
Answered on 29th Jul 2023 - Member since Jan 2023 - report
"Hi Andy, yes you are correct, in reality they should have asked you and it would have been down to your personal preference as to whether they tie in the tiles to your roof using the old ones, if it didn’t cross your boundary then it wouldn’t be a problem you could solve. As for whether they should have reused the old tiles on the neighbours roof, the answer is no, however if the customer requested they do so, all the roofer can do is advise. Kind regards"
Answered on 29th Jul 2023 - Member since Nov 2021 - report
"Hi if I was renewing the roof I would have asked you what you would prefer, new tiles or the same tile second-hand weathered tiles to match yours,"
Answered on 29th Jul 2023 - Member since Jul 2023 - report
"personally if i was doing the roof i would of done as you say and updated new tiles."
Answered on 14th Aug 2023 - Member since Jun 2023 - report
Find Tradespeople, compare up to 3 quotes!
It's FREE and there are no obligations
Ask a Trade
Got a question that only a tradesperson can answer? We have thousands of trades ready to answer any question you may have.
Ask your question
Ask a Trade

Are you looking for advice on a DIY project or have a question for our tradespeople?

We'll email your question to tradespeople who are skilled in your chosen category.

Your question will be made public - please do not include any personal details.

{{ first(ask.errors)[0] }}

By continuing you agree to the Community Guidelines.

Report Content

{{ first(reportForm.errors) }}

Thank you

Your report has been created and will be investigated shortly.

Ready to get a price for your home improvement project?
Get started

Over 1 million homeowners and over 50,000 tradespeople
use MyJobQuote nationwide each year